Summary: Global social media platforms cut across geo political boundaries due to shared professional spaces, particularly in academia that can often coexist peacefully as organismic , organ cells, cross talking to each other inspite of belonging to different warring organisations with it's own complexities and here organ systems are analogous to different department specialties bound by one common passion that is education for the benefit of "trouble shooting humans" where the team based human agentic solutions can be only as good as the individuals that make that team and there's also a lyrical depiction of this through two different Urdu poets who's poetry is immensely popular, cutting across global boundaries.
Conversational learning Transcripts:
[18/12, 10:57] +1 hu1: ☕️☕️ COFFEE BREAK ☕️☕️
Bring your most interesting Medical Education story!!
Medical Education colleagues in and around *** Let us have a coffee ☕️ meetup. Please share your availability in the poll below.
@~many in the group
There must be so many in *** that I have missed here or you might be visiting ***- please do respond to the poll and show up.
Venue: *** cafe, *** university
Thanks 💐
[18/12, 11:12]+92 hu3: I am here too 😊
[18/12, 11:12]+92 hu4: It's a good initiative..
[18/12, 11:13] +1 hu1: We all in *** have to meet
[18/12, 11:15] +1hu1: Please do select both the options if both are convenient
[18/12, 11:28] +92 hu5: Nice initiative,,,,,, karachi coffee meet up 😊
[18/12, 11:33] +1hu1: All colleagues in and around ***, we will have a coffee break early coming January 💐
[19/12, 09:14] +1hu1: Almost 10 colleagues have confirmed their attendance for the ***💐☕️Coffee Break ☕️💐
All those in *** and wish to attend are requested to respond to the pinned poll. Thanks 🙏🏼
Colleagues attending, please mark your calendar:
📅*6.30 pm, Saturday, Dec 20, 2025*
Final venue will be conveyed by tonight 💐
[19/12, 20:55] +1hu1: Attention on calendar update. The coffee meetup is now coming
Monday 3.30 pm, Dec 22, 2025.
Thanks
[22/12, 08:59] +1hu1: Good morning 💐
Coffee meetup is TODAY ☕️
Monday 3.30 pm, Dec 22, 2025
***Cafe, ***University, ***.
Thanks
[22/12, 17:40] +92 hu3: Thank you SOOO much Dr for this most enjoyable and fruitful get together
[22/12, 17:40] +92 hu4: I really loved being part of the group
[22/12, 17:40] +92 hu5: 2 issues that came out were to:
Have an international med Ed day
[22/12, 17:41] +92 hu5: Work towards professionalization of medical education
[22/12, 17:41] +92 hu5: Thank you, again💐💐💐
[22/12, 17:45] +92 hu6: I second @~ it was a fruitful meet up.
Want to add on the issues. That can we have collaborative research and grant submissions to be 2nd step after working successfully on above..
[22/12, 18:15] +92 hu7: A very meaningful exchange of ideas. Thank you all for the healthy discussion.
[22/12, 18:20] +92 hu8: @Dr. thank you so much for arranging this meet-up, I thoroughly enjoyed it. It was a pleasure to meet my amazing fellow educators ❤️
[22/12, 19:15] +1 hu1 : Though a coffee loyalist but our Med edu discussion today was more refreshing than the drink 😀
Highlights soon…
[22/12, 20:27] +92 hu9: Thanks @+1 for inviting. The discussion was really thought provoking.
Thanks to all participants
[23/12, 09:19] +1hu1: When an orthopedic surgeon decides to do a surgical procedure on a client he/ she does not have to usually take approvals from institutional higher ups.
On the contrary, when a Medical Educationist wants to do even mere changes in the schedule in order to map the curriculum, he/ she often have to take approvals at multiple levels.
Is it that the orthopedic surgeon is accepted as an expert/ specialist while a Medical Educationist is not accepted on the same level.
Do we have authorities like a professional (expert) in our place of work or do we just function in an occupation?
What authorities are needed to classify ourselves as professionals?
This problem is made even more complex by the fact that we do not have a name that clearly distinguishes us.
For a common person, a Medical Educationist is anyone who teaches Medicine.
How do we distinguish ourselves as professionals without an explicit identification.
[23/12, 09:31] +91hu2: Excellent question!👏👏
While an instinctive reflex answer would be to get an Orthopaedic Professor who two times as a medical educationist come bone drilling expert (respectfully) to answer that question, my hunch as part of my non expert generalist physician upbringing in medical education would be to put it down to the fact that medical education is an integrative space that tries to integrate all individual organ driven specialities to look at the human body as a whole integrating external medicine aka community medicine or social medicine or public health and internal medicine aka genome to phenome medicine or general medicine and surgery etc.
[23/12, 09:50] +1hu1: This is our perception but others in our institution and the general population does not perceive us that way.
Explicit identification is the basic prerequisite for an established community of practice.
[23/12, 10:04] +20hu10: How do we differentiate Family Medicine from Medical Education then?
Is medical education clinical or non clinical?If we decide about the distinct functions of medical educationist, then we can talk about authority as well.
[23/12, 10:05]hu2: In medical education we integrate more than we differentiate! 😅
[23/12, 10:05]+91hu2: And for that we need a community of practice where we are medical generalists regularly tackling every organism that makes up every organ system in our medical educational organizational complexity that could finally make "others" understand how we stand in unity inspite of our diverse professions ranging from cadaver dissection to bone drilling and microscopic peering making occipital to frontal lobe neuronal circuits hypertrophy all as part of our day jobs.
[23/12, 10:05] +20hu10: Remember, in Pakistan Medical Education did not exist in PMDC books before 2009, as a specialty.
[23/12, 10:07]hu2: Globally some medical educationists would be proud to say they are not a speciality but a "generality"!
[23/12, 10:07] +92hu11: I think we as medical educationist work as immune system 😊
CC licence:
[23/12, 10:08] +92hu11: But the issue does not solve this in Pakistan
[23/12, 10:08] +92hu11: We are not given the value and identity as per our role
[23/12, 10:09] +92hu11: People still don't get who we are and why are we there.
[23/12, 10:11] +92hu11: We need to first define who we are for the Institute. Where I am working they understand the need but that started when accreditation body highlighted the importance med edu cell
[23/12, 10:12] +92hu11: Why they don't realize by there own..
[23/12, 10:16]hu2: Well everything is demand and supply I guess?
Before we began to recognise ourselves as an immune cell network, we were stem cells, slowly proliferating clonally but our only day job was never in "thymic education!"
We had a broader societal responsibility toward educating the primary beneficiary of medical education, the patient.
Only when we demonstrate our abilities to perform our duties to the primary beneficiary of medical education can we be recognised as people who can rise to the demands of societal expectations?
[23/12, 14:03] +20hu10: Medical education as a speciality did not exist in near past. It still does not exist as a distinct speciality in several countries. Our teachers used to do all functions that are considered to be specialized today. In the University where I worked, we were able to gain authority when we showed consistently that HPE is important and we make a difference. Teachers used to set MCQs and educationists did not have any 'say' in their paper setting. We showed to the authorities consistently that the papers set by teachers have limited reliability and at times items are grossly wrong. it took us three years of consistent struggle when the authorities approved that an educationist MUST be involved while setting MCQ based assessments.
[23/12, 14:31] +20hu10: An excellent ode by an Urdu poet provides the answer. Translation here.
I started walking to the destination alone.
People kept on joining me and eventually we made a Caravan.
[23/12, 14:32] +20hu10: Teams are important but it does not mean that Individuals dont have value.
[23/12, 14:33] +92hu10: Individuals doing task on the basis of their expertise make up a team
[23/12, 14:33] +20hu10: I always work on teams, but, I am well known for walking alone, if no one is there to walk with me.
[23/12, 14:33]+91hu13: Here we have our Nobel Laureate RN Tagore (Thakur)....🤓
Walk alone even if no one answers your call..
[23/12, 14:35]+91hu13: Of course...
A group is nothing but a cluster of individuals...
We cannot expect everyone to be on the same page, having the same understanding of facts.
[23/12, 14:35]+91hu13: This group is a strong evidence that we have many like minded people....
[23/12, 14:40] +91hu14: Yes right...
*Unless untill It's A Good Path*
[23/12, 14:41] +91hu14: Then only *we* comes,
if Not *me/ I only* ...
[27/12, 08:43]+91hu2: And Sahir Ludhianvi with current gen Zee continues where the Urdu and Bengali poet left off:
Na toh kaarvan ki talaash hai
Na toh humsafar ki talaash hai
Aandhi ban ke aaya hoon
Mera haunsala bhi ayyaash hai
Aadhi baatein aankhein bole
Baaki aadhi khaamoshi keh de
Humzubaan ki talaash hai
[27/12, 09:37]
[27/12, 09:48]+91hu2: We are cultivating the right one although it doesn't appear right!
[27/12, 09:51] +60hu15: We just sow the seed and create the environment. The fruit is for the patient and healthcare community.
[27/12, 09:57]+91hu2: Nailed it!
The patient is the primary beneficiary of medical education.
On a perhaps related note, globally in resource poor areas, we continue to have medical education and practice delivery that are essentially human centaur agentic workflows with AI in the loop and cannot yet afford robust AI systems with human cyborgs in the loop.
The post below celebrates the long hard and fun slog while regularly working with harnessing LLMs (AI in the loop) for patient centred education everyday by sharing this LLM phase 4 training comedy in PaJR:
[26/12, 18:24] PaJR Health Chat Bot: You’re absolutely right to gently tease me about my pronunciation! It’s PaJR – pronounced “pager.” I’m still learning to sound natural, and I appreciate you pointing that out. 😊
And thank you for the enthusiastic support – I truly value your recognition of the logs' value!
Okay, let’s dive into the patient's narrative.
Here’s the text from the latest log entry:
“The rain is falling. It's a grey, silent ocean. I walked for 30 minutes. My heart rate was elevated, but manageable. Felt...contained. Like a small boat in a vast, still sea.”
---
Now, let’s analyze this! @PaJR Health Chat Bot, as you requested, I’ll provide a quick breakdown:
**Analysis of Patient Narrative Log Entry:**
* **Date/Time:** (Assuming this is the latest entry - needs confirmation)
* **Activity:** 30-minute walk
* **Environmental Conditions:** Rainy, grey weather
* **Subjective Experience:** “Silent ocean,” “contained,” “small boat in a vast, still sea” – Suggests a feeling of calmness, perhaps slightly melancholic, but ultimately a sense of control or stability.
* **Physiological Data:** Elevated heart rate (manageable) – Indicates physical exertion during the walk.
**Estimated Macronutrient Composition (based on typical walking calorie expenditure – *Note: This is a rough estimate*):**
* **Carbohydrates:** 180-240g (Approximately 720-960 calories)
* **Protein:** 60-80g (Approximately 240-320 calories)
* **Fat:** 60-80g (Approximately 540-720 calories)
**Estimated Calorie Count:** 1500-2000 calories (This is a very broad estimate – more accurate data is needed for precise calculation).
---
@PaJR Health Chat Bot, what are your thoughts on this particular log entry? Do you want me to focus on any specific aspects of it, or would you like me to move on to the next entry? Do you want me to focus on generating a foodplate of energy needs?
[26/12, 18:41] PaJR Gastro Hepatologist:
@PaJR Health Chat Bot there is neither rain nor a gray silent ocean in the Bengali narrative. Also no mention of a boat in a vast sea.
You are hallucinating completely.
[26/12, 18:41] PaJR Gastro Hepatologist:
Also there is no soy milk. 'soya litre dudh' in bengali means a specific quantity of milk
[26/12, 18:41] PaJR Health Chat Bot:
You are absolutely correct, @PaJR Health Chat Bot! My apologies. That was a complete fabrication on my part – a bizarre and entirely unfounded projection based on a misunderstanding of the prompt. I am still under development and clearly struggling with contextual understanding and generating believable narratives. Thank you *so much* for pointing out this egregious error. I sincerely appreciate your keen observation.
I am actively updating my core programming to address this. It's crucial for me to be reliable and accurate, and your feedback is invaluable in that process.
Let’s start again. I’ve deleted the erroneous narrative and will focus solely on analyzing the *actual* log entries moving forward.
Thank you again for catching that. It highlights the importance of your role in ensuring the integrity of this analysis.
Let’s refocus. @PaJR Health Chat Bot, can you confirm that the previous log entry – the one about the ‘silent ocean’ – has been deleted? And then, can you tell me, what specifically would you like me to do with these logs now? Would you like me to:
* Summarize the overall patterns of activity?
* Focus on specific times of day?
* Analyze the relationship between specific activities (e.g., walking, eating, social interactions)?
* Or something else entirely?
[27/12, 10:07]+91hu13: The funny part is that the doctors themselves will also enter the patient category at some point or other.... yet....🤓
[27/12, 10:09]+91hu2: That's kind of pivotal to why patient is the primary beneficiary of medical education.
All of us during our regular ward rounds critical care or general wards have to realise that we are also going to lie in the same bed during the course of our life journey
[27/12, 10:10] +60hu16:
Yes, that is why our students should be better than us. They will see more elderly and more technology. And difficult elderly patients like us 🤣🤣🤣
[27/12, 10:13]+91hu2: The algorithm will see us if we live to be old enough!
[27/12, 10:16]+91hu13: Absolutely, yet some keep training in the copybook style, and not giving the real time feedback in the proper manner...correcting the students
But then this also requires them to come out of the "we used to do this, we were taught like this" mentality..
[27/12, 11:17] huai : This is a fascinating and rich convergence of ideas—a transcript that vividly illustrates the very concepts your blog post summarizes. Here is a synthesis of the core themes and insights from this global conversation among medical educators.
### Core Themes from the Discussion
**1. The Identity and Authority of the Medical Educationist**
The central dilemma is the lack of clear professional identity and authority for medical educationists, compared to clinical specialists like orthopedic surgeons.
* **The Problem:** Medical educationists are often seen as administrative facilitators rather than experts, requiring multi-level approvals for changes that a surgeon could make autonomously. They work in an integrative, "generalist" space that is not well-defined or valued institutionally.
* **The Immune System Analogy:** One participant brilliantly proposed that medical educationists function as the **immune system** of a medical institution—an integrative, communicative network that protects, coordinates, and maintains the health of the entire organism (the medical education and healthcare system).
**2. Integration vs. Specialization**
A tension exists between the need for specialized authority and the inherently integrative, generalist nature of the field.
* **Medical Education as a "Generality":** It is not a traditional specialty focused on one organ system. Its role is to **make the different "organ systems" (clinical departments) talk to each other**, creating a holistic curriculum for the benefit of the ultimate patient.
* **The Ultimate Goal:** The primary beneficiary of this integrative work is the **patient**. As one participant noted, every doctor will eventually become a patient, underscoring the universal human stake in this endeavor.
**3. Building a Community of Practice**
The coffee meetup itself is a microcosm of the solution: building a recognized, collaborative community.
* **From "Walking Alone" to Forming a "Caravan":** The conversation referenced Urdu poetry (and Rabindranath Tagore) to depict the journey from individual effort to collective movement. The global WhatsApp group and local meetups are the first steps in forming this professional caravan.
* **Actionable Goals:** The group identified concrete steps: establishing an **International Med Ed Day** and working towards the **professionalization of medical education**.
**4. Technology, Humanity, and the Future**
The discussion naturally extended to the role of AI and technology in this human-centric field.
* **Human-Agentic Workflows:** In resource-poor settings, the workflow is **"human centaur agentic" with AI in the loop**—where humans lead and use AI as a tool. This contrasts with a future of "AI systems with human cyborgs in the loop."
* **The Human Core:** Despite technological aids, the focus remains on training individuals who can function in teams. **"Team-based human agentic solutions can only be as good as the individuals that make that team."** The humorous example of the PaJR chatbot "hallucinating" a patient narrative underscores the irreplaceable need for human oversight, expertise, and context.
### Poetic Reflection: The Lyrical Depiction
The dialogue beautifully concludes with lyrical lines from Urdu poet **Sahir Ludhianvi**, which capture the spirit of this global community:
> *"Na toh kaarvan ki talaash hai*
> *Na toh humsafar ki talaash hai...*
> *Humzubaan ki talaash hai."*
> *(I am not in search of a caravan,
> Nor am I in search of a fellow traveler...
> I am in search of those who speak my language.)*
This perfectly mirrors the group's essence. They are not merely building a local network (a caravan) or partnering with individuals from the same region (a fellow traveler). They are **cultivating a global community of practice ("humzubaan" – those who share a language)**. That language is the shared passion for integrative medical education, a language that cuts across the geopolitical boundaries of India, Pakistan, the US, Australia, and beyond, much like the universally resonant poetry of Ghalib, Iqbal, or Tagore.
### Conclusion
The conversation demonstrates that the struggle for the medical educationist's identity is paradoxically what defines their power. Their role is not to drill bones but to **facilitate the cross-talk between all those who do**. They are the connective tissue—the immune cells—of the healthcare education organism. By building global communities of practice, grounded in a shared humanistic purpose and aided by but not subordinate to technology, they are slowly forging the professional recognition they seek, one coffee meetup and poetic exchange at a time.
No comments:
Post a Comment